An
Israeli economy obsessed with security is an Israeli economy doomed
Both Likud and Labor have failed thus far to consider the
full import of their economic decisions, pushing forward an astronomical military
price in exchange for civil development.
By Ghassan Joha, Star Staff Writer
JORDAN (Star)
- Three weeks ago Egypt celebrated the 20th anniversary of the liberation of the
Sinai Peninsula from Israeli occupation. Israelis commemorated the occasion as
well in their own way; weeping over what might have been.
This year's anniversary revived memories of that time,
when the repercussions of an Egyptian-Israeli peace treaty were still reverberating
throughout the Middle East.
Israel's Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, then acting as
defense minister, was aligned with other hawkish Israeli politicians in their
derision of the Israeli government's decision to sign on to the Camp David peace
treaty, signed between Israel and Egypt in Washington in 1979.
Then Prime Minister Menachem Begin was fully aware of
the political and economic consequences of his decision to turn back Egyptian
territory to its legitimate heirs.
Though Sharon was one of Begin's strongest allies, he
would not let the Egyptian affair pass that easily, pushing on Lebanon until war
broke out and then occupying half of it.
This issue is made all the more relevant today when examining
the policies Sharon has been pursuing against the Palestinians over the last year
and a half. When Begin accepted peace with Egypt it cost his maturing economy
some $16 million for the dismantlement of Jewish settlements and army camps in
the Sinai. Today the Israeli economy has lost more than $15 billion in less than
two years. It is the first time in Israel's history to suffer such a blow-all
this to satisfy Sharon's thirst for Palestinian blood.
In April of 1982 the Israelis had not lost a single life.
As of today Israel has lost more than 550 people throughout the course of the
20-month-old Palestinian Al Aqsa Intifada. That figure is sure to rise as Sharon
readies his troops for a dance in the Gaza Strip.
Recent statistics indicate the Israeli economy has entered
the deepest recession since its establishment 54 years ago. Sharon is not ignorant
to this. Official statements put unemployment as high as 5 percent, this in a
nation of 6 million. Unofficial statistics suggest the rate sits closer to 10
percent-taking into consideration the influx of Jewish immigrants from the former
Soviet republics.
Comparing Israel's past with its present reveals a great
deal about the mentality of the current Israeli leadership when dealing with the
economy. Former PM Begin advanced from the Likud Party, the same as Sharon, and
seemed to transfer a similar economic ignorance to him.
But the Labor Party is not immune to this economic obstinacy.
Labor's Shimon Peres was in opposition to Begin in 1982, but stood behind him
for the so-called "Israeli security" supposed to be secured by the war in Lebanon.
Both Likud and Labor have failed thus far to consider
the full import of their economic decisions, pushing forward an astronomical military
price in exchange for civil development.
Israel's currency, the shekel, has seen its value plummet,
all for sake of the cause-continuing atrocities designed to yield the elusive
concept of Israeli security. In April the shekel lost 11 percent of its value
against the US dollar, resulting in an exchange of five shekels for every dollar.
Twenty years ago withdrawal from the Sinai didn't affect the shekel nearly as
severely.
Consider as well the 1.2 million Israelis living in poverty,
25 percent of whom are children, and it becomes clear the past and present Israeli
leadership is not focusing on maintaining a country, but on fighting a low-grade
war with their Arab neighbors. Over all these years the names have changed, a
bit, but the policies have remained the same. These policies, this paranoia, are
sure to be the nation's undoing as much as any resistance from the outside. The
only way out is for Sharon to recognize the undisputed facts and withdraw from
all the Palestinian territories his hard-line predecessors occupied in the 1967
war. He will have to do this in direct opposition to legislation these men pushed
through.
In 1982 Begin proposed a law to the Israeli Knesset (parliament)
forbidding the dismantling of any Jewish settlement in the West Bank and Gaza.
That type of mentality is why 20 years later Israel sits in the current economic
and military mess.
Today, each of those expanding 220 Jewish settlements
in the Occupied Territories is costing Israel $5 million per month. This despite
the fact that over 65 percent of Israelis believe the Jewish settlements are worthless.
Even the Jewish settlers realize this fact, yet none appears ready to make the
change.
Sharon is indecisive when it comes to economics. He appears
to believe once his security issues are solved the economy will return. At the
present rate it will take decades for that recovery, and that's assuming this
mythical idea of security is ever realized-something that seems less and less
likely as Israeli military policies become more and more brutal.
Sharon's presence in 1982 until today suggests some of
his policies are based in a twisted sense of pride, not logic, when he promotes
ever more expenditure and watches his nation fall ever deeper into recession.
Security is not the answer for the Israeli economy. Peace is.
May 18, 2002
Sources :
The Star |